I mean, film version have some huge flaw

submitted by
I mean, film version have some huge flaw
28
44
1

Log in to comment

Hot Top New Old

Tom Bombadill was an insane add to the story.

“Yeah I thought it would be interesting to have a guy who could just end the story but he loves his girlfriend too much.”

 reply
7

I really think he just wrote himself into the story.

 reply
6

He did, sorta: Beren and Lúthien <3

 reply
3

Comments in Lord Of The Rings Memes@lemmy.dbzer0.com

This meme, but with the scouring of the shire

 reply
35

Eh it would have been great, but as Jackson said, it feels like a 2nd climax after the death of Sauron.

 reply
19

It could be another movie. Probably will be eventually.

 reply
7
edited

Could have been an interesting way to do Amazon’s series instead of just shitting over the silmarillion. Fill in the lives and occurences after lotr. Woul’dnt need Saruman or Wormtongue as the extended trilogy deals with them and they’re not strictly needed for the scouring.

 reply
5

Amazon got IP for simarillion not lotr.

 reply
5

I think having the elves come to help men was the biggest disrespect to Tolkien.

 reply
8

Sometimes I wonder what Tolkein would think about memes like these

 reply
15

Glamdring should have glowed white in the presence of orcs.

 reply
4

Removing that PoS character from the movies was the single best thing Jackson did. Tom Bombadil is the fucking worst, I hate every single page that contains that obnoxious character.

 reply
6

While I wouldn’t use such harsh words, removing Tom Bombadil was the most obvious decision in any adaptation of anything ever.

 reply
37

Yeah, leaving him in would have had general audiences focused too much on why he didn’t get involved.

 reply
13
edited

Yeah! Don’t want the plebs looking into the justifications for not eschewing the wizard drama for simply hanging out at the river with your hot AF, insatiable wife, ya know? 🤷🏼‍♂️

 reply
10

He should have smoked pipe weed with the eagles.

 reply
5
edited

He is representative of concepts that are very important to Tolkien’s setting and themes, though. I think it is also intentional that he has an unlikeable tone or doesn’t quite fit in, in a weird way. It adds to his mystique.

 reply
26

Annotating a horse cock with his name is an insult to horse cocks

 reply
5

Nah, he’s the best! He’s just a merry fellow :3

 reply
0

I think half a horse cock deserves a nsfw tag.

 reply
-6
OP

No no no it’s a third AI leg

 reply
15

5th?

 reply
2
OP

Let me chug this 20L bottle of water, yes you’re absolutely right ! Thank you for pointing me my error, it’s really a third legs

 reply
8
Insert image