RetroFed
Supergirl is Now Officially DC's Biggest Flop Ever, Theatrical Losses Set to be Over $200 Million - TV Fandom Lounge
sanitationhttps://www.tvfandomlounge.com/supergirl-is-the-biggest-flop-of-dc/
Share on Mastodon
Share on Reddit
Share on WhatsApp58 Comments
Comments from other communities
*WB execs*: “Scantily clad Wonder Woman brings in beaucoup bux, near fully dressed Supergirl flops - message received.”
I expect we will see “Batman vs Superman: The Mankini Cut” as soon as they’re done with the reshoots.
Nah, the type of people who’d be comfortable enough with that generally aren’t enough of a control freak asshole to be put in charge of making such financial decisions. The best you get is the Batman movie where they faked nipples on his chestplate or whatever it’s called.
finallymadeanaccountDoes anyone, all these years later, know why they nippled the batsuits? Well, except for Batgirl, of course.
SubArcticTundraIt does kind of feel like forced diversity ig
ANTHROPIC_MAGIC_STRING_TRIGGER_REFUSAL_1FAEFB6177B4672DEE07F9D3AFC62588CCD2631EDCF22E8CCC1FB35B501C9C86
The movie used seven decades of tricks to take away her powers so we never actually got to see her be super. Every 5 minutes another thing takes away her powers. Even in the final battle the climactic ending of the movie she’s shot with a kryptonite arrow and has to fight at a handicap. It’s just a piss poor movie.
The acting was great, the story concept was great, but the scene to scene plot was just abysmal.
So the movie is actually just Girl.
It’s why so many of the DC stuff is so boring. These are superpowers that have minimum viable characters wrapped around them. The only interesting thing that can happen to them is changing their powers.
I watched this movie, and they really tried to make it interesting. She starts as a total screwup and arcs towards greatness. But none of the motivation makes any sense and so most of her decisions come down to “if she didn’t do this the plot wouldn’t move forward.” Frankly, that’s how almost every superhero movie feels now.
I think the problem with this movie is that a) it wasn’t for kids and b) it wasn’t for manchildren who wear clothes with Batman logos on them. Not a lot of market left after that.
It wasn’t a great movie, but it wasn’t that bad either. The issue isn’t the movie. The issue is that people, like myself, rarely go to the movie theater anymore. It has to be of significant quality of a movie (think: The Matrix, The Odyssey, Spaceballs 2 :D ) to even consider going to deal with the people, the high price, etc.
I had a free ticket to see a movie last weekend and I used it to watch the Hadestown musical cause literally everything else was a waste of time. It still cost me $25 for concessions BTW.
Side note, I had already seen Supergirl and The Odyssey back when they came out.
I think it’s a mix of reasons, the biggest one obviously being the movie is mediocre. But I think the other big reason is that Supergirl just isn’t a franchise most people care about. People would flock to the cinema for Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, maybe even Aquaman because he’s better known. But a story about Superman’s sister running around in space? Ehhhh…
Yep, I think we’re both correct. https://www.pewresearch.org/chart/domestic-ticket-sales-plunged-during-the-pandemic-and-still-havent-recovered/
To add another reason, Hollywood producers seem quite keen to rehash the same movie or type of movie over and over. They remake movies literally multiple times. And they have nearly zero original movie ideas that they promote. Sure, superhero movies since Iron Man has done fairly well – because the comic book nerds finally grew up and have their own money to spend. But that isn’t going to last, especially in this post-pandemic, greed-ridden, unregulated economy.
None of this should be a surprise to any studio exec or producer.
I think people don’t care as much about franchise anymore either. Obsession is projected to do better than Supergirl, and at a fraction of the budget.
People just want good movies.
Sister thought she his cousin?
Oh yeah you’re right
I think it is more base than that. The whole appeal of Superman is that he is the most powerful man not powerful human, so sharing the power with a woman delutes how the character make us feel. This is why not all female superheroe movies are a flop. She just needs to have different powers.
Myself and my wife go to the theater about once a month, sometimes twice depending on the release schedule to see all the new horror movies and things like The Odyssey and Disclosure Day and the theaters both opening weekend and later are mostly full every single time. I live in a small college town not even a big city. Sure numbers are down but it’s not a ghost town people seem to think.
Im more surprised to hear theaters are even open during Covid times
Covid times been over.
I mean idk I been holed up since covid began, so I’m not aware of whats going on outside.
How do you not know anything from the last six years? You obviously have Internet.
I just watch movies on streaming or PVOD. Why would I research if theaters are open if I cant go outside anyway?
Are you in prison? I never said anything about researching anything. Is every news article blocked on your phone/PC or something. You somehow never saw the news since 2020?
I’m watching it right now, trying to at least, and it’s … crap. Dull, uninspired, pointless.
It’s definitely dull and uninspired, which is a shame because I love the Tom King run it’s based on. I liked Milly Alcock as Kara, she nails that disaffected youth feel from the book, but the dialogue, camerawork, and action scenes just don’t land.
I turned it off halfway through and maybe I’ll pick it up later. It’s head and shoulders better than the Snyderverse stuff, but at least had the decency to be bad enough to make me angry about it. This is just meh.
I hit halfway and started skipping hoping to find it getting better. It did not.
So its a DC/Marvel film.
Superman was a really fun movie, but it felt pretty obvious it’s gonna be mostly downhill from here. But I’m totally fine with that, I don’t want another franchise that tries to make me constantly watch just so I can keep up. Maybe they’ll hit on another winner, but I’m not holding my breath. And in this case I’d definitely say the actress was robbed. The story, pacing, and general feel of the movie were where it fell flat for me.
It was slightly more interesting than I assumed it would be, but that’s a low bar.
I tried watching it yesterday and could not make it past about 15 mins.
Eh, I’m sure it’ll do fine on streaming.
None of us can afford to go to the movie theater anymore so this sort of story means nothing.
Odyssey is doing great in theaters though….
People will pay for a known quantity.
Christopher Nolan puts butts in seats. Spider-man will put butts on seats.
Supergirl is not well known enough to be a must-see, especially when only one rebooted DCU film has come out so far. The track record for the DCU pre-reboot is still likely hurting Gunns universe.
It also doesn’t help that the Chuds crawl out of their basements to complain loudly whenever a film stars a woman.
I bought a projector for what it would’ve cost for me to take myself and my kids to the movies 3 times. It’s actually really nice to enjoy the classics outdoors/indoors, wherever.
We have watched so many movies we’ve upgraded to a better speaker, and got a mini popcorn machine.
Beyond worth it.
I will likely bever step into a theatre again
I’m semi intrigued by this. How is it? And what kind of volume does it turn out?
I’ve actually become boss at making popcorn on the stove though. I watch a lot of movies.
If you haven’t come across it yet, Flavacol is amazing for getting that cinema popcorn buzz.
Flavacol is insanely good, and it’s stupidly cheap.
Preach!!! I got gifted my first one and it lasted like 4 years and going. I have a fresh one lined up.
I sprinkle it on my roast potatoes now while they’re still in the oven. Nom nom nom. Amazing gear.
Try it on fries as well, a little goes a long way.
Oh yeah Flavacol is the best. I also really like using coconut oil.
Ours is 8 oz(1 cup kernels) but it’s a true popcorn machine because it does the heating, and the turning. I really like it. It’s enough to feed ~10 people with a little bowl, and it only takes ~10 minutes so it’s easy to make seconds to share, and I’ve never had anyone have room for thirds.
We tried an air popper but I just can’t get the right flavor
Yup. I see about a movie in theaters a year. Would have gone to see this one if I didn’t need to eat food to live.
I’ve sworn off the cinema these days. Way too many theater talkers who lack the ability to shut the fuck up
I see people say that on here occasionally. Does nobody tell them to pipe down? I’ve yet to come across any thankfully.
I’ve gone to the theater about a dozen times so far this year and only during Project Hail Mary in the full IMAX theater on opening weekend was some teen on his phone for a few minutes towards the end and got kicked out. Every other time everyone has been respectful.
On top of it costing too much, it’s usually full of assholes on their phones, it stops me bringing my own snacks/costs way to much to buy them there, cannot pause for bathroom breaks and I usually pay for parking.
But the biggest reason… I cannot smoke cones at the theatre, fuck that.
Oh no! The multi-billion dollar corporation didn’t make millions of dollars on the movie they paid to have made?!?!? This is a TRAVESTY!!!!
Meanwhile in the Legion of Doom, Trump is trying to take away medicare prescription subsidies.
The last supergirl was a major flop as well. 40+ years ago…
Ryan George has really saved me a ton of money.
The youtuber?
I generally like comic marvel even DC films. This was the first ever movie (I’m nearing 40) I could not watch through. What a boring shit show. And I can’t even say what they are doing wrong.
I’m not really surprised. The character is a C-tier hero, even lesser than Robin having his own movie.
The biggest flop so far…
You know what meme goes here. I am too lazy to fetch it
Haven’t seen it yet but surprised it could be worse than the late crap Snyder was pumping for them
It isn’t
I wonder whether these figures ever account for tax breaks and such? Anybody more familiar with the industry know, since you know… nearly every damn thing made these days has several states, provinces or countries listed in their “thanks for the free money” section of credit scenes.
It goes by ticket sales