But pretty sure Timmy Chalamei sees the future, and sacrifices his humanity and the humanity of his children for the good of the human race.
He didn’t just think he’d be a good ruler, he was snorting a bunch of actual magic fairy dust and legitimately able to see the future and knew what it would take to save humanity: his own.
It’s a typical space Jesus story, so of course he’d just be another deluded space asshole, if he wasn’t really is Space Jesus in the story.
He didn’t just think he’d be a good ruler, he also knew his involvement would sent in motion a catastrophic jihad that would drown the universe in blood.
He knew he was the opposite of Jesus and that his family were just like the Harkonens but more subtle
Yes, but also… while the jihad would lead to billions of deaths, the state of the galaxy at that time was so stagnant that him not acting would lead to far worse results. So Catch-22 - he was doing the best thing for the very long run, and just didn’t have the ability/strength/balls to go far enough himself.
I know he suddenly regretted what he was starting but did he not have the balls or is drowning the universe in blood just such a momentous task that one guy and a planet of extremists can’t do it all in a single generation of time?
Okay fuck it, gonna reread it now. Maybe this will make me want to watch the show
I seem to remember it’s a bit of both. Paul already has the problem of suddenly being able to see all the paths. To stay sane just from that point is commendable. But that’s a lot to carry. Still not as much as his sister, who never had a chance to form her own identity before being hit with knowing everything from past mothers, with everyone in her head.
Haven’t read the last few books yet, but I believe that further into the future there’s a greater threat coming which humanity can only survive by being used to adapting and spreading through the universe.
It’s commentary on the current political climate using a relatively well known situation as a reference point, not a restatement of the point of the book.
Also I just checked again and have to retract what I said about the book ends. Apparently the last chapter had Jessica consoling Chauni about the poligamy situation, which is way weaker of a final note than I remembered
But Fenrig knowing he could murk Paul and somehow being immune to Paul’s omniscience was pretty cool. I forgot I really liked that character
RetroFed
inari
Share on Mastodon
Share on Reddit
Share on WhatsApp
Leto II: No see you just didn’t do it hard enough. You must become a predator their bones remember.
You need to become worm Pharaoh
Not a huge Dune fan…
But pretty sure Timmy Chalamei sees the future, and sacrifices his humanity and the humanity of his children for the good of the human race.
He didn’t just think he’d be a good ruler, he was snorting a bunch of actual magic fairy dust and legitimately able to see the future and knew what it would take to save humanity: his own.
It’s a typical space Jesus story, so of course he’d just be another deluded space asshole, if he wasn’t really is Space Jesus in the story.
Tap for spoiler
He didn’t just think he’d be a good ruler, he also knew his involvement would sent in motion a catastrophic jihad that would drown the universe in blood.
He knew he was the opposite of Jesus and that his family were just like the Harkonens but more subtle
Yes, but also… while the jihad would lead to billions of deaths, the state of the galaxy at that time was so stagnant that him not acting would lead to far worse results. So Catch-22 - he was doing the best thing for the very long run, and just didn’t have the ability/strength/balls to go far enough himself.
I know he suddenly regretted what he was starting but did he not have the balls or is drowning the universe in blood just such a momentous task that one guy and a planet of extremists can’t do it all in a single generation of time?
Okay fuck it, gonna reread it now. Maybe this will make me want to watch the show
I seem to remember it’s a bit of both. Paul already has the problem of suddenly being able to see all the paths. To stay sane just from that point is commendable. But that’s a lot to carry. Still not as much as his sister, who never had a chance to form her own identity before being hit with knowing everything from past mothers, with everyone in her head.
His sister didn’t see the future.
Ah, that’s right. So only really maddening, and not totally.
I never understood why the stagnant situation would be worse
Haven’t read the last few books yet, but I believe that further into the future there’s a greater threat coming which humanity can only survive by being used to adapting and spreading through the universe.
Maybe a spoiler since I don’t know the movie touches on it, but besides Paul’s father they are all Harkonnens or part Harkonnen.
Shit, really sorry my b
The book is out for decades, I think its ok to say
Got me! I need sleep
Woah crazy, that was the point of the book. 🤯
I don’t think this tweet was meant as a mindblowing novel take on the book
Perhaps I am dumb. It’s been ten years I could have swore this was in the final paragraph thesis so it seems like a weird thing to joke about
It’s commentary on the current political climate using a relatively well known situation as a reference point, not a restatement of the point of the book.
Ooh, I wouldn’t have caught that. Thank you.
Tap for spoiler
Also I just checked again and have to retract what I said about the book ends. Apparently the last chapter had Jessica consoling Chauni about the poligamy situation, which is way weaker of a final note than I remembered
But Fenrig knowing he could murk Paul and somehow being immune to Paul’s omniscience was pretty cool. I forgot I really liked that character